Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (2024)

In this post, I want to talk about swing trading.

Question from Kevin: I’d like to ask you what’s your time frame for swing trading? 6-8 weeks? I currently have an identity crisis in terms of my trading style. I realized if I transition from a swing trader to a position trader, I would make more gains at the expense of being able to execute less trades.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (1)

Here’s what I have to say about this.

The definitions are firm. There are definitions for specific rules, such as stop sign.

You have a stop at the stop sign; it means full stop. It doesn’t mean slow down, look both ways, and keep going.

The same thing here. If you look at it really as a definition, yeah, six to eight weeks is a typical definition. But the reality is when we look at something, it also depends on market conditions and volatility. The whole point behind swing trading is letting a run as far as possible in that trend or at that moment. That’s the whole goal or point.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (2)

Here we had a pullback. If you were to look at swing trading in this stock somewhere around 2017 well, that swing trade could be a two-year hold if you’re on the longer timeframe. If you’re looking at things on a weekly basis.

However, if you’re looking at things on a daily or daily basis, a swing trade could be that right here.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (3)

This is what I’ll say most people do. Let’s say you have that breakout in August. And you let that run continue until about September, and that’s when things stall out.

That happens because if you’re running for 4-6 weeks to the upside with minimal pullback eventually, you’ll get a few of those red days or where things start to pull back. That’s why they have that in that definition. Now, it can be longer depending on if you’re taking profits into strength.

Let’s say you get into a stock a little bit earlier. And things go up, and you take half of your position off somewhere after a couple of months.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (4)

And you have a pullback, and then you add to it well you ride and keep working that swing trade.

You have that initial position that was very good. It’s not an ideal answer for you. Maybe it’s not as specific of what is a swing trader, but you look at it as a portfolio whole as a lump sum. If you have $10,000, you can use $2,000 for speculative trades. Another $2000 might be in cash reserves. $2,000 might be in long-term investments. Another $2,000 could be in swing trading.

If we take out the swing trading definitions, you know look at it as whole time. Some of them are going to be as long as possible. Other trades, your total portfolio might be a little bit shorter. Some will be even shorter.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (5)

You have a few trades that might be a very short timeframe. And some trades probably somewhere in between there. You have a mixture of whole times, and that also means position sizing, and that’ll help mix things up.

But you don’t have to be any single one trader because then you’re confining yourself into the box. I always say when it comes to learning about anything that you only believe 50% of the things that I say, and then the other 50% learn on your own. And gather additional insight because that way, you’re open to new things. That way, you’re open to embracing other ideas and concepts.

If you’re just 100% all-in swing trading, day trader or day trader penny stock with options, you’ve specified yourself that you have no room to diversify your income.

Specificity is essential when it comes to:

  • choosing a business
  • choosing a niche
  • targeting a customer

However, when it comes to investment, diversification is the right approach because you’re looking at sustaining your capital.

Anytime you get a pullback; you’re looking to preserve that capital.

I hope that gives you some ideas and perspectives on swing trading, trying to figure out your identity.

You don’t have to be one individual in the markets. You could pick one thing and do it time and time again. But remember, as far as your cash goes, allocate it into a few different spots.

Identity Crisis on Holding a Stock... Swing Trader? Day Trader? #HungryForReturns 34 - Tradersfly (2024)

FAQs

How long should you hold a swing trade? ›

Typically, swing trading involves holding a position either long or short for more than one trading session, but usually not longer than several weeks or a couple of months. This is a general time frame, as some trades may last longer than a couple of months, yet the trader may still consider them swing trades.

What is the average return on swing trading? ›

We've seen estimations that as many as 90% of swing traders fail to make money in the stock market – meaning they either break even or lose money. That suggests that the average swing trading success rate is somewhere around 10% – meaning 10% of swing traders actually bring in profit over the course of a year.

Is day trading more risky than swing trading? ›

Is Day Trading Riskier Than Swing Trading? Both day trading and swing trading comes with significant risks. Generally speaking, the greater the risk, the greater the profit. Day trading plays on smaller price movements, so the risk is lower than swing trading.

Which is more profitable swing trading or day trading? ›

Swing trade positions have a better potential for larger gains and losses than day trade positions since they are generally open longer. Because each trading approach is unique, traders should select a strategy that suits their talents, interests, and lifestyle.

Can you make a living off swing trading? ›

One of the main benefits of swing trading is that while it doesn't take much time, you can earn large profits for the time invested. This trading style can be anything you want it to be. If you are willing to dedicate yourself entirely to it, you can easily earn a living through swing trading alone.

Who is the most successful swing trader? ›

Paul Tudor Jones - Another famous swing trader is Paul Tudor Jones. Jones is a billionaire hedge fund manager who is known for his aggressive trading style. He is one of the most successful traders of all time, and he has a net worth of over $5 billion.

What is the 2% rule in swing trading? ›

Additionally, there are golden rules in the swing trading game. There is a 2% rule that says one should never put more than 2% of account equity at risk. On the other hand, there is a 1% rule that says the loss on a single trade should not exceed more than 1% of your total capital.

What is the 1% rule in swing trading? ›

The 1% risk rule means not risking more than 1% of account capital on a single trade. It doesn't mean only putting 1% of your capital into a trade. Put as much capital as you wish, but if the trade is losing more than 1% of your total capital, close the position.

What is a good moving average for a swing trader? ›

20 / 21 period: The 21 moving average is my preferred choice when it comes to short-term swing trading. During trends, price respects it so well and it also signals trend shifts. 50 period: The 50 moving average is the standard swing-trading moving average and very popular.

What is the downside of swing trading? ›

The biggest con of this trading tool is the overnight risk. Swing traders hold positions for several days, which increases the risk of market gaps due to unexpected news or events. Another drawback is that many new traders may mistake false signals for trends.

How much money do day traders with $10,000 accounts make per day on average? ›

With a $10,000 account, a good day might bring in a five percent gain, which is $500. However, day traders also need to consider fixed costs such as commissions charged by brokers. These commissions can eat into profits, and day traders need to earn enough to overcome these fees [2].

Why is swing trading so hard? ›

Swing trading can be difficult for the average retail trader. Professional traders have more experience, leverage, information, and lower commissions; however, they are limited by the instruments they are allowed to trade, the risk they are capable of taking on, and their large amount of capital.

Is it better to swing trade or hold? ›

Returns (Profit & Time)

We're going to discuss both the profit these styles return and the time it takes you to earn that return. Without a doubt, swing trading offers better returns – both in terms of profit and time. You may earn less profit percentage per swing trade compared to investing – that much is true.

How much do average swing traders make? ›

How much does a Swing Trading make? As of Apr 20, 2024, the average hourly pay for a Swing Trading in the United States is $12.19 an hour.

What is the most profitable time to day trade? ›

The opening period (9:30 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. Eastern Time) is often one of the best hours of the day for day trading, offering the biggest moves in the shortest amount of time. A lot of professional day traders stop trading around 11:30 a.m. because that is when volatility and volume tend to taper off.

How many hours a day for swing trading? ›

Most often, I trade the daily and 4hr charts. On a daily chart, a new candle appears every 24 hours. As a result, I can look at the chart only once a day. On a 4h chart, there are 6 candles in a 24-hour period meaning that I can do whatever I want and come back to my trading desk at 4-hour intervals during the day.

What is the success rate of swing traders? ›

However, it's important to note that an estimated 90% of swing traders do not make money. This suggests that the average success rate of swing traders who do earn a profit annually is about 10%. As such, swing trading isn't a get-rich-quick scheme, but a strategic approach that requires skill, patience, and discipline.

How long should you hold a day trade? ›

Day traders typically complete their trades within the day and avoid holding positions overnight, with the exception of the Forex Market.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5795

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.